242. Examining the The Hyles Church Manual - Part 6 - From Salvation to Salesmanship: When Soul Winning Becomes Closing the Deal
Episode Notes
We take a deep dive into the Infallible Hyles Church Manual. We hope you enjoy.
To Purchase James' New Release "Freedom from Depression": a.co/d/05pENtog
To Purchase our cigar line go to: 1689cigars.com/collections/4-freedom-cigars
Our Experience Box: 1689cigars.com/collections/4-freedom-cigars/products/the-4-freedom-experience-box
To purchase James' Book "From Brokenness to Freedom" a.co/d/c7UX3xT
For more info visit our website: 4freedompodcast.com
For Merch visit this site: www.teepublic.com/user/freedom-ministries?utm_source=designer&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=Gq_E0abDp_8
Transcript
Welcome back to the 4 Freedom Podcast. What a great day it is to be here with you.
I feel like me and Brett haven't talked in like a month as far as on the podcast. It hadn't been that long, but it's been a couple of weeks with Brett being out of the pocket.
And I think he's got some news he may want to share here in a little bit. But, man, we had a great couple of weeks. We had a revival here at our church. I got to run to Tennessee,
and I got to see John and my buddy Andrew Maddox for a day and hang out with them. And it has been just a crazy time. Our revival at our church was awesome.
I had a buddy of mine from Georgia come up, Stephen, and preach for us and just really challenged us. He preached through Hebrews too,
Brett, and just a Christ-centered view of life. And, man, just a great, great time. And so how are things in the Mississippi world with the old Brett Martin? Well, I'll tell you, James, one thing that's very interesting that I should announce right now to you and everybody out there is that officially right now I am full-time 4-Freedom Podcast.
Like my only job right now is this podcast. It's my sole source of income.
We're going to make a living out of this no matter what. What is it, a million now you're making a year? Is that about what it is? Exactly. Oh, that's a quarter. Just a little south of a million, huh? Right, right.
But in all honesty, I am jobless right now because I'm in between churches.
I have resigned as pastor of Rocky Point Baptist Church because I've accepted a position at Puckett Baptist Church in Puckett, Mississippi.
It's about an hour and a half south of where I am right now. And it's kind of in the south of Jackson, south of Jackson, not South Jackson, but south of Jackson area, kind of below Brandon, Mississippi. And I had a couple weeks off to get the house moved.
We're moving Friday down there. Moving trucks coming to pick us up. And so, you know, a little life transition there, you know. My first Sunday at the new church is November 15th.
So I've got a couple of weeks. I've got to run to Michigan for a week and perform a wedding ceremony up there for my nephew. And then we'll come back and get started at the new church. Excited about it. I'm very thankful to Rocky Point for the last four years.
I've taken real good care of me and my family. We've wanted for nothing.
But we're excited about this new direction that the Lord is pulling us. It was 100% God's will.
100% God knew what he was doing when he set this thing up. It seems like everything kind of fell into the place to the in place to the point where the only health insurance we have right now is through Emily job.
Well, just so happens that her job has another store near the other church.
And so she was able to transfer to that store and keep our health insurance. And so that's definitely been a blessing.
Yeah, things are just kind of lining into place and clicking right along. And we're very thankful for what the Lord is doing. And I really think he's in this move.
He's in this transition. And I think it's going to be some great things on the horizon. Hey, man, that's great. So you could say you're transitioning.
Is that right? That's right. Amen. Yes. I always get that on the record there, just making sure everybody knows that. But, man, that's exciting. I've been praying.
I've been able to have a little bit of the backside, backseat story and all that and praying through all that. And so it's good to see when God works in ways we don't see behind the scenes and just how all that planned out.
It's just been exciting for you guys and looking forward to what God has for you. Still continuing with your masters.
Still continuing with the podcast. You're not stepping away as far as I know of, are you? No, I'm here.
You've got me. I'm not going anywhere right now. Hook, line, and sinker was what we had there at Champion.
We'll talk through a couple of things here in a minute about some of that. But love it.
Brett, you were supposed to be at the Mississippi Baptist Convention right now. They are former president of the National Convention and also a pastor that's local here. Clint Presley is there speaking at the Mississippi Baptist Convention. And he's a great guy.
I appreciate what he stood for when he was there looking forward to Willie Rice, which we're still trying to get Willie on the episode here in a couple of weeks. Hopefully, we'll get him lined up. We've been talking to his people. So, we're excited about that.
Oh, yeah. I'll tell you, they got some heavy hitters this year. You've got Clint. You got Moller's down there. Oh, I know. Oh, yeah. Moller's down there. He's been doing the Bible Treasures.
And like I said, I really wanted to be there. I go every year. But like I told you before we started recording, I mean, I'm moving Friday.
And there's no way I could have went to the convention and have my house ready to move on Friday. And so, I had to cut the convention this year.
And I hate it because some of my buddies are down there and posting about some things going on. But, you know, some things work out that way, you know. Let me say this. I will say that I did think about going into church planning.
I was really considering that for a while as an option. I even talked to several pastors about support for going into me.
And you've had several conversations on church planning. And while I do still have a heart for church planning, this church kind of opened up. But this opportunity kind of came to me.
And I did feel the Lord leading in it. And so, this is the direction we went. But like I said, I'm still excited about what God's got for us.
Yeah, that's exciting, man. Excited for that. And definitely be praying for you guys through this process. And the family, you know, that's always a tough time. Thankfully, your kids are a little older. So, not as crazy transition. You know, hour and a half isn't terrible when they're driving with friends and things.
But a couple of things. Housekeeping. If you haven't checked out our cigar line, go and check out that. It's doing well, Brad. I just set up an event and sold 200 cigars.
And I'm trying to reinvest that back into the company to launch a couple new lines over here in the new year. And hopefully, you'll go by and check out that. We'll be having some things coming up that I know you'll be excited about in the future.
And if you haven't checked out our website, go by and check it out. Got a lot of resources on there.
Some things for you. Someone, or when the Howl's 100th birthday came out, that episode a couple weeks ago, I shared it to a couple different groups, Brett. And apparently, just last night, the Preacher Boys podcast page approved that post to be shared. And my phone blew up with messages about it.
Like, I can't believe you guys are still worshiping Howl's. Look at all this mess. And finally, Daniel Wynn came to our rescue. And he said, hey, just so you guys know, they're not endorsing Jack Howl's.
It's actually pretty satirical of just what is happening since he passed and how people are worshiping him.
He said from the comments, it doesn't sound like you guys listened to the episodes at all. You need to go check it out. So, Daniel, I appreciate you giving us a plug there and coming to our defense. I had made one comment and just said, hey, go check it out.
Let us know your thoughts. So, I always appreciate that. Wow, that's crazy that they thought that we were celebrating.
You know, I got a shrine of Howl's 100th birthday, you know. Yeah, that's what they thought. So, it was great. One person commented and said, a podcast and cigar company talking about Jack Howl's. This is ironic. So, I thought it was good. But, yeah.
All right, Brett, any other things before we jump in? No, it's fall weather. It's that time of year. It is so nice out. It is super nice out.
We're just excited to be here. And I think we're ready to get started. Well, let's get this show on the road. For freedom, you set me free. Not for change, not for guilt, not for Pharisee. Grace lit the flame, now I'm puffing peace. Cigars and victory justified, released. Welcome to the 4-Freedom Podcast.
This podcast exists to bring the freedom of the gospel for everyday Christians with everyday issues.
I ain't saved by dress codes, not by what I eat. I'm covered in the righteousness, washed from head to feet. No tally of tradition, no man-made code.
Blood bought my freedom, now I ride that road. They clutch pearls when they see smoke rings rise. But my praise still ascends past the legalist cries.
Christ plus nothing, that's the real math. So miss me with your fence laws and your extra path. He sat with sinners, I'm sitting with saints. Sipping grace from the bottle, no room for fakes. I light one for liberty, toast to the king. Every ash a sermon, death has lost its sting.
For freedom, you set me free. Not for change, not for guilt, not for Pharisee. Grace lit the flame, now I'm puffing peace. Cigars and victory justified,
released. For freedom, you set me free. Not for change, not for guilt, not for Pharisee. Grace lit the flame, now I'm puffing peace. Cigars and victory justified, released.
Let grace begin. For freedom, you set me free. Not for change, not for guilt, not for Pharisee. Grace lit the flame, now I'm puffing peace. Now here are your hosts, James Safrit and Brett Martin. Welcome back to the 4-Freedom Podcast. We are continuing to examine the Howe's Church Manual.
Today we're going to be looking at this next chapter. I think it's the heart of some of the concerns that we've had throughout this series. The title of the book of this chapter that we're looking at is called A Soul Winning Experience. I like how you titled it, Brett. From salvation to salesmanship.
When soul winning becomes closing the deal. Unlike some of the previous chapters, this one isn't a list of instructions for running a ministry.
According to the chapter, Doug was led to Christ by Jack Howe's during a home visit from 1960. The conversation was later relived as a demonstration of how to win someone to Christ. Doug eventually became a deacon at First Baptist. And so Howe's presented this as an example of some successful personal evangelism.
So before we continue on with that, Brett, I want to get your talk. I'll share sort of my time of how we were trained.
And maybe you can even go back to your home church, how you were trained to have personal evangelism, how you were taught at Howe's.
And then we can sort of talk back and forth for a minute, sort of our upbringing. Well, I remember coming up in church growing up, we were taught the Romans Road. That's what it was on our track. And so we were made to memorize the verses.
And the preacher kind of took us through. We went to the Christian school. And so he kind of took us through how to lead somebody to Christ, you know, because we go soul winning every week. But I remember when we were at Howe's Anderson, we took a personal evangelism class.
And I'll tell you, there's a clip out, real famous clip of this guy that's preaching at the pulpit of First Baptist Hammond.
And he's out there and he sees a guy out there talking. And he just stares at him. And then he just rips into him. How dare you speak? I'm up here.
I'm, you know, I'm important. Listen to me. And then the guy can't let it go. And he just stares at him. He talks for a few, preaches for a few minutes and then comes back and says, I hope you're not a Howe's Anderson College student.
You're just awful. And he just, he berates the guy. And over and over, that guy's name is Larry Smith. Okay, Larry Smith was my personal evangelism teacher. We used to make fun of the way he would talk. Hello, I'm Larry Smith.
And that's how he talked. And I remember he was a real peculiar guy. A man named J.L. went into the cheese business in Chicago. He failed and went bankrupt. Hey, sir. Quit you talking over here. Hey! Quit you talking. I'm talking to you, sir. Thank you. God bless you. I'm preaching.
He went into the cheese business. He failed. He went bankrupt.
You're probably the guy that needs to be at the altar tonight. Hope God you're not a Miles Anderson student. I hope God love you.
I hope if you're going to be a preacher, everybody in the audience talks while you preach. You'll reap what you sow, son.
That's right, man. Still love you. Amen. He would make girls cry in his class because he had this rule that, you know, you don't. How did he put it?
Don't make a statement. Ask a question. Well, there was this one girl. She wanted to ask a question about a soul winning scenario, but she had to set up the premise. So she started talking and then was going to ask her question. And he said, don't make a statement. Ask a question.
And he would get louder and louder every time he said it to the point where he's just yelling at her and she's crying her eyes out. And he'd be in the middle of lecturing. And when somebody would close their eyes to doze off, he'd scream and wake everybody up. It was crazy.
Anyway, they taught us the Romans road as well. And it was the,
you always ask the same question. It is, you know, if you die today, you're 100% sure you go to heaven or would you have some doubt about it? You always put that, would you have some doubt at the end of it? Man, he hammered that into us.
And we all did it the same way. It was ABC, pray after me. And, you know, it was kind of like an always be closing type deal. Very salesmanship. How to, somebody gives you a question,
defer the question, bring it back. And I know this is common stuff. You know, when you're giving somebody the gospel, that's a common thing to defer the question. So I'm not criticizing that, which is very formulaic.
One size fits all. One, two, three, pray after me type formula stuff. Yeah. Growing up, you know, I remember the very first time I went door to door.
So when it was a guy who's willing to be with Lord now, his name is Melvin Deal. And Melvin was, he was a deacon in our church, chairman of our deacons for as long as I can remember up until just recently. He stepped down before he passed away.
And he'd get up and preach and he'd go to these truck stops and preach at truck stops and outside holding signs. Well, we did a Thursday men's soul winning and maybe a Saturday morning.
And I don't remember which one it was, but I went with him and I'd never been soul winning door knocking a day in my life. And so all I had was my Bible and I'm like following along.
And he said, Hey, why don't you go with me? And a couple of teenage boys went with us. And so we're walking along with him.
And as we're walking along, we go to this apartment complex duplex system.
And he knocks on the door and he said, just watch me and learn how to do it. I said, that's great. So he knocks on the door. And Brett, he goes into the plan of salvation like he's done it a million times. Leads the person to Christ. Person's crying.
And I'm like, dude, this is the most amazing thing ever. I'd never seen it done before. And so one time,
it's all it was. And he looks at me and he goes, all right, next one's yours.
I didn't know what I was doing, Brett. I had no clue. I'm not this guy's door. I'm like 16, 17 years old. This guy comes to the door. I mean, he's got a beer in his hand. He opens the door. What are you doing here? And I said, I'm James Safrit.
And I'm from the local church down the road. I'm stumbling over my name because I don't even know what to say here. And he goes, oh, blankety blank, get off my doorstep and just slams the door in my face. And I remember, I mean, I felt like three inches tall.
I'm like, dude, I don't even know what I'm doing. And so he lovingly, he showed me some things and talked to me. And so we continued to that. So I go to Gospel Life. I go to Arkansas for college.
And I've never really been formally trained. I think we had a personal evangelism class. Maybe one of the missionaries taught it.
But all I remember at Champion was they taught what was called Operation Go with David Wood. Have you ever heard of Operation Go, Brett? I haven't. Same system. You go through the plan of salvation.
We did a lot of that going around and talking through and role playing and all that.
But David Wood's big thing was when you get to the point where that person's ready to accept Christ,
you tell them to bow their head and close their eyes. Because you pray, and you know, the Carl Hatt story was you'd grab them by the shoulder and you'd squeeze their shoulder a little bit. His was you'd start praying with them.
And then you'd stop your prayer like halfway through. And you'd look at them. You'd just say, if you want to accept Christ, reach out and grab my hand.
And you wait. You wait for them to grab your hand. And as soon as they grab your hand, now repeat after me. One, two, three, A, B, C, however it was. You pray. They repeat. You accepted Jesus. Amen. We're never going to see you again.
So that's how we were taught. Larry Smith did the same thing. He taught you put your Bible out.
And then if you want to, in the middle of prayer, you stop. And if you want to accept Christ, your Savior, put your hand on the Bible.
And they put your hand on the Bible. And then you lead them into prayer. And a lot of times, the thing was, don't ask them if they want to accept Christ. Because it gives them an opportunity to say no.
Because how dare they do it of their own heart? They got to be manipulated into it.
And so you got to, don't ask them. Just get into the prayer and then get to that point and try to, I mean, I don't want to go to hell. Put the hand on the Bible. And so, yeah. So, yeah. Same methodology. Absolutely.
All right. So here, let's jump back into it. Here's where this chapter of the Howells manual begins to get interesting. Because we're not sitting here trying to argue Jack Howells didn't preach the gospel. You know, in this conversation, he explains that all people are sinners. Sin brings death and judgment.
Jesus died for our sins. Salvation comes through faith alone in Christ, not through religious works. And those, Brett, are all fundamental truths that we can get behind. In fact, these are things that I preach on a Sunday morning every single week. But as the conversation progresses,
you begin to notice something else. Howells isn't simply explaining the gospel. He's working toward a particular response.
And once he gets the response, he begins working toward another one. By the time this conversation ends in this chapter, Doug has repeated the salvation prayer, taken Howells' hand as confirmation,
told his wife he became a Christian, and then repeated another prayer promising God that he will walk the aisle at First Baptist Hammond the following Sunday. Brett, I think this progression gives us a lot to talk about. Because the question isn't whether we should evangelize.
The question is whether our approach to evangelism can become so focused on securing a decision that we begin treating salvation like closing a sales transaction,
where we begin to, how can we convert this into a transactional moment that's going to make me look better to the public?
Right. And I think that's exactly where we need to go with this chapter, because I want everybody listening to understand something about me. I believe in personal evangelism. I'm not saying I don't. I believe Christians ought to share the gospel.
I believe pastors ought to visit people and talk with them about their souls.
I believe we should call people to repentance and faith.
I don't have any interest in criticizing somebody simply because he went into a home, opened his Bible, and told somebody about Jesus. To be honest, I wish more Christians were doing that.
And one of the things that stood out to me about this conversation is that how actually takes time to build a relationship with this man.
I mean, as I walk through the door immediately and say, Doug, if you die tonight, would you go to heaven? He talks about the family, their background, Doug's guitar playing, his work.
I mean, where they moved from, how they enjoyed the church. I mean, he listens to what Doug says. That's a good thing. People aren't just evangelistic prospects.
They're human beings. We want to treat them that way. But I also think at the same time, this chapter is particularly important because of the culture surrounding it.
We're not recording this episode in a vacuum. You can go back and listen to the other chapters that we've covered. We've already seen the emphasis of soul winning numbers in the Sunday school chapter.
We've seen the bus ministry focus on attendance and promotional campaigns. We've seen the music chapter describing how music can influence emotional responses during invitations.
And now we get to a demonstration of how somebody is personally led to Christ. I think we need to ask whether some of these same tendencies are showing up here. Because when a church culture places enormous emphasis on how many people you personally win to Christ,
there's a temptation to develop a method that reliably gets someone to say yes, get someone to go. I don't want to teach people how to go. I want to teach people how to faithfully explain the gospel, answer questions, call for repentance and faith, and trust God to save.
I mean, if I have to manipulate the yes out of you and I never gave you the option, then how many false professions, probably countless false professions have been made because of that? Yeah, I agree.
And we're going to walk through this chapter a little bit differently than the past because we're going to try to bring out some of the things that are said to help you understand the chapter. So let's start where Howes gets it right because there are some things worth acknowledging.
Doug tells Howes that he grew up Methodist, that he and his wife have been looking into Catholicism. And Howes says in the book he doesn't immediately launch into an attack of one denomination versus another denomination.
He tells Doug that church membership isn't what's going to get someone to heaven. He uses the illustration about a bus station. The station isn't what you get.
I'm sorry. Your station isn't your destination. It's where you meet the transportation that does.
His point is that Jesus is the one that saves, not the religious institution. My pastor growing up used to say,
going to church doesn't make you a Christian just as much as sitting in a garage makes you a car. And it's the same thing.
Just because you go to church doesn't make you a Christian. But I think this is the distinction here. In the culture where somebody might assume that being a Baptist, a Methodist, a Catholic, or something else automatically means you're right with God, isn't the situation.
Howes then goes on to tell him that he knows, ask him whether he knows he has eternal life or not. Doug says that he doesn't think anyone could really know for sure until death. And so Howes takes him to 1 John 5, verse 13,
which is a legitimate passage on assurance. And then, as you said, he begins to walk him down the Romans road. Romans 3, the wages of sin is death. Romans 6, Christ died for our sins. Romans 5, salvation through faith alone in Christ.
Romans 10, of all these things, he begins to walk through what this is. And Doug raises a concern that faith involves keeping commandments and living a good life.
Howes looks at him and responds by explaining that good works aren't what makes someone God's child.
He says that the Holy Spirit comes and lives within a believer, helps them live a certain way of a certain lifestyle. And again, that's real gospel content that he's given.
In fact, if we ignore everything else in this conversation and simply evaluate whether Howes explains that we're sinners and we need Christ through salvation, I would say he's done a phenomenal job here.
He's relayed the important biblical truth. He's talked about what we need. And that's why our criticism has to be very precise in this passage.
Because the problem isn't that he opened Romans and explained that we're sinners and we need a Savior. The problem is what happens as the conversation moves toward Doug making this decision for Christ.
And I think that distinction is vitally important because people hear criticism of this style of soul winning and immediately assume we're criticizing evangelism itself. And we are not.
The Romans road is a useful way to explain the gospel. It's the only way I still today share the gospel of someone because the verses are so entrenched in me is I have the Romans road. There's nothing wrong with having passages ready or knowing how to organize the gospel conversation.
If somebody asks me how to be saved, I want to be able to open scripture, explain it clearly.
But the gospel is more than a sequence of statements that somebody agrees with.
You can intellectually agree that you were a sinner and that Jesus died on the cross and that heaven and hell are real and still not genuinely repent and trust in Christ. James 2 tells us that even the demons believe certain truths about God. So saving faith isn't merely agreeing that facts are accurate.
And here's where I think the gospel conversation begins to get interesting. Before Hiles starts explaining the gospel, he asked Doug something along the lines of,
If I could show you in the Bible how to know you're going to heaven and you could see what to do, would you do it? Doug gives a qualified answer. He says he believes that he would if he could agree with what Hiles was showing him. Hiles asks essentially the same question again,
getting another agreement before proceeding. Now, there's nothing inherently wrong with asking somebody whether he's willing to consider scripture.
But we got to notice how the conversation is being structured. Okay. Before the explanation even begins, Hiles is trying to establish a commitment that if the information is demonstrated,
Doug will act on it. Now, that sounds very similar to a sales technique where you secure agreement on the conditions of a purchase before you make your presentation. It doesn't prove manipulation by itself.
But when you combine it with some things that we're going to talk about in a minute, there's some things that happen later on in the chapter. I think there's a pattern that develops that we got to talk about. Yeah, that's the important theological distinction that we have to look at here.
The gospel is not merely a proposition that says, here are four facts.
Do you agree with these four facts? It's the announcement of what God has done through Christ Jesus, accompanied by a call of repentance and belief. In Acts 2, Peter proclaims Christ crucified, risen,
and people, the Bible says, are pierced to the heart. In Acts 16, the Philippian jailer asks, what must I do to be saved? Paul and Silas tell him, believe in the Lord Jesus Christ. Throughout Acts, people respond in different circumstances,
but the apostles proclaim the same essential gospel without relying on one rigid conversation script.
It's so important for us to know this because we treat a particular evangelism method almost as if, though, it were a biblical method. We also have to notice that Howes gets Doug to participate by having him read individual words from verses.
He'll begin quoting verses from Romans, stop, and have Doug supply the next word. In one sense,
you know, I understand that. I've done that before. I've had people read verses, but you're keeping the person engaged with the Bible. And, Brett, don't get me wrong. This is not a bad thing, but it creates a rhythm where Doug is repeating, supplying the expected answer.
So when Howes asks him a question, Doug agrees. Howes affirms the answer and then moves to the next step.
Again, I'm not saying this is automatically wrong, but what we're saying is teachers do this all the time. When we're dealing with someone's eternal destiny, we need to make sure we're not confusing the ability to give an expected answer that we're actually without actually understanding that.
I would rather someone stop me halfway through something, the gospel presentation or a theological conversation, and have a different difficult question and be able to talk through that than simply giving the answer that I think they want to
hear. One of the things, Brett, we do a daily devotion every morning with our family. Kids are up by six at the breakfast table at 630, eating their breakfast. I open up a book. It's called Sticky Situations. And we read this. It's a little two-minute story.
And they give me a response of how they think they should respond. Practical life applications. And I share a verse. There's some questions,
some supplied answers, and we talk through it as a family. And one thing that we've noticed, me and Allison, we'll ask them a question, and they know the answer. They've been raised in church. They're pastor's kids.
And we'll ask them that question, and they'll know how to answer it. And then Allison will look at them and say, well, yesterday at school, this similar situation happened. How did you respond to that? And they'll say, oh, I didn't respond that way.
And what it's doing is it's teaching them, hey, it's good to know the answer, but how are we living this out? And it's the understanding this fundamental fact of do we just know the answers in our head, or are we actually living like the gospel truly changed us? Exactly.
And that's one of the biggest concerns with formula-driven evangelism is when you train somebody that's successful soul winning means getting through the presentation,
reaching the prayer, and anything that interrupts that process can start feeling like an obstacle. The person has a theological question, but you want to keep moving.
The person isn't sure what repentance means, but you want to get to the next verse. The person says he believes in Jesus, but doesn't understand why his own goodness can't save him.
And rather than slowing down and dealing with that, you may be tempted to get him to agree with the next statement.
And then eventually you arrive at the moment where you ask him to pray. But I'm not interested in simply getting somebody through my presentation.
I'm interested in whether that person understands who Jesus is and what sin is, what Christ accomplished through his death and resurrection, and what it means to turn from sin and trust him.
Now, that doesn't mean a person has to pass a seminary examination before he can be saved. Thief on the cross didn't have a theology degree. But genuine faith has an object, and that object is Christ.
And if moving so quickly toward a decision that doesn't have time to understand what the person actually believes, then I need to examine my priorities. The goal of evangelism isn't completing my script. Okay? The goal is faithfully communicating Christ.
We had that. Those who listen to this podcast who have meant to Bible college understand what a script is because they worked at AmeriCall.
They worked as telemarketers like we did. We had a script.
And, you know, when they ask you this question, the script would tell you, okay, here's how you answer that and how you get back to the original call.
Well, you know, I don't need to let, you know, and sometimes you have to do that in a gospel conversation, but I don't need to let, you know, House Church Manual tell me, defer everything and get back to the script.
But I don't need to let the Holy Spirit say, okay, this is something that if we don't deal with it, he's not going to understand what I'm talking about. We need to deal with it now. As opposed to this is a distracting question. They're asking, try to distract from this.
So I'm going to defer it or I'm giving an answer real quick. And Jesus did this masterfully with the woman at the well because she asked the question about worship to distract, you know, what your map, you say that, you know, Jerusalem is a place for the worship, but we worship
on this mountain. That was a distracting question. But Jesus answered it in a way that we got back on topic without dismissing her.
And Jesus was a master at that. Yeah. You said AmeriCall. Now, in Arkansas, it was called AmeriHealth. It was at the same place. Oh, yeah. I think, you know, think that one's an official name. Okay. Okay. Gotcha. Gotcha.
So let's take a look at just a moment here of where Piles begins to apply what I like to call the spiritual pressure to make this decision. Because I think this is the part of the chapter that becomes the most concerning. After explaining sin, judgment, Christ's death, and faith,
Piles then tells Doug that his wife, Kathy, is a Christian, but he's not. And then he presents a hypothetical situation. If their partner were to burn that night, both of them were to die,
Kathy would go to heaven and Doug would go to hell. They would never see each other again. He tells Doug that this frightens him.
And now the reality of judgment is biblical, and we should not be embarrassed to warn people about hell. I preach on hell. I think just as much as you do, Brett. Jesus warned about judgment.
Paul spoke about the wrath of God. The fact that an evangelist warns somebody of hell isn't manipulation by itself.
But I think whether the question here to be asked is whether we use this primarily to explain a biblical truth or to heighten the emotional pressure where Doug has already said that he believes the gospel claims that Howells
has presented. Now Howells begins to introduce this possibility of a house fire that very night, followed by a permanent separation of Doug and his wife. Now, this picture is deeply emotional and manipulative.
It plays on the fear of death and the fear of losing someone that you love. The question is whether helping someone understand his condition before God or whether we're trying to create an urgency to secure an immediate decision.
I think there can be a legitimate place for a warning and telling someone about life is uncertain. But we should never feel that we have to frighten someone into making a profession before we're willing to end the conversation. I remember sitting on the preaching of Ralph Sexton Jr. at a youth conference.
And he got up and he told a story about a young lady. And I think I've shared it on the podcast before.
But he shared a story about a young lady and how she stood up at the end of the invitation. And she cursed Ralph Sexton and said, I'm not going to accept your Jesus.
I'm going to go out here and live my own life. And she walked out of the Coliseum and a car came in and popped the curve and pinned her up against the side of the Coliseum. And the whole bottom half her body was decapitated.
And that evening she died walking out of that building not knowing Jesus. He tells this story in vivid detail. And then he looks at the congregation, the young people that are there.
And he said, is that going to be you? Are you going to be the one that walks out of here and doesn't accept Jesus and gets hit by a car on the way home tonight and be eternally separated from God? And it's this emotional declaration, which it's true.
If they don't accept Jesus, they're going to be eternally separated from God. But he's taking this situation that he's emotionally manipulating someone into accepting Christ and not allowing the gospel to pierce the heart.
Paul didn't get up and or Peter didn't get up and manipulate them. It says that the word of God was preached and it pierced their heart and they said, what must I do to be saved? Exactly.
And, you know, one on one personal evangelism, you know, I've shared the gospel with many people over the years, but I don't think I've ever done that in a one on one gospel conversation. It's told somebody,
you know, if you don't pray this prayer in a minute, you know, you're never going to see your wife again because you're going to burn in hell. I've never done.
I've never done that. Now, once it's over and they have accepted, I might say something along the lines of, you know, if if you went out there 10 minutes ago and got hit by a truck and died, where would you would have
went? You know, and that's part of my training. That's what I was trained to say at my home church and at House Anderson.
But now that you've accepted Christ, where would you go? You know, we've done that, but I've never done that.
Trying to push somebody to say the prayer, threaten them with hell right then and there. I mean, tell them it's a danger. But then to do like this where, you know, you'll never see your wife again. You know, I did hard, solid manipulation there.
And I want to be careful here because the last thing that I want to do, I don't believe we should sanitize the gospel. Hell is real, folks. Judgment is real. Life is uncertain. We are not guaranteed another moment.
OK, I'm not going to apologize for telling somebody that if he dies apart from Christ, he faces judgment. OK, that's biblical truth.
But there's a difference between telling the truth about judgment and deliberately pushing somebody's emotional buttons.
OK, when Hiles brings Doug's wife into the picture and tells him that they'll be separated forever if their apartment catches fire that night, he's moving beyond explaining Romans into a very personal, emotional appeal.
You know, maybe his motive was sincere concern. I have no reason from this conversation alone to say he didn't genuinely care about Doug. But sincere motives don't automatically make every method wise or right.
And there's another issue. The gospel calls people to Christ because he is Lord and Savior, not merely because they're afraid of a hypothetical tragedy tonight.
Fear of judgment can certainly awaken somebody to his need for salvation. But biblical repentance and faith involve more than wanting to avoid hell or stay with your spouse after death. I want someone to understand that his sin is against a holy God and that Jesus Christ is the only Savior.
I want him to see the beauty of the gospel, not just the terror of judgment. And if he says, Pastor, I need some time to think about what you've shown me. I'm not going to treat that as a failure. I'm going to keep talking with him. I'll pray for him. I'll answer questions.
But I don't need to make him feel like he must repeat a prayer before I leave his living room or all things or it's just the end of the world. I wasted my time. That's not true. New Testament tells us that, you know, Paul plants, Apollos water. Someone else gets the increase.
You know, the word of God never, it always reaps. It never goes that returns vain.
Yeah. And, you know, this one brings us to the actual prayer. This could be the most revealing part of the entire conversation. I was asked Doug whether he believes God would save him if he bowed his head and trusted Christ.
Doug responds with this statement in the book. Well, I think he would.
And Owls assures him that God would and asks him to bow his head and pray aloud for Doug.
And then while their heads are bowed, tells Doug to talk to God in his own words and ask forgiveness. He encourages him to do it aloud. But the transcript doesn't record Doug giving a prayer. He encourages that, but it's not recorded.
Instead, Owls says that perhaps praying is difficult or Doug can't think of the words. So he offers a prayer for Doug to repeat phrase by phrase.
Doug repeats these words, asking for forgiveness, receiving Christ and trusting him for heaven. Now, I don't believe there's anything inherently wrong with helping someone express their faith. I've done it before, especially when you're talking with younger people. They've never prayed before.
Older people as well. But I'm concerned that when the evangelist keeps supplying the next action after the person doesn't initiate it himself.
I mean, Owls is saying, Doug, pray this prayer in your own words. It doesn't happen.
And immediately he provides the words. Then he asks Doug to take his hand as a sign that he meant the prayer. He now says that he's received Christ and afterward asks him whether now he believes in the Son of God. Doug says yes. The chapter presents this genuine conversation.
We have no basis for declaring Doug wasn't saved. But we also shouldn't teach that the repeating of a prayer and squeezing a preacher's hand is also a reliable proof of regeneration.
I mean, it could simply be, man, I just don't want to be separated from my wife. I don't even know who this Jesus is, but I want to be with my wife forever. And that's the reason he's saying these things. Right. And, you know, I don't have a problem with the sinner's prayer.
Just like you said earlier, I don't have a problem with sinner's prayer. I use sinner's prayer every time that, you know, I lead someone to Christ.
I know there are people out there that knock it. I don't have a problem with it. What I do have a problem with is people thinking that it's the prayer that saves. It's not the prayer that saves. It's the belief behind the prayer.
And all the prayer does is, you know, is give you a way to verbalize that.
It gives you a way to confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord. But you believe in the heart, you know. And I think that's, you know, Romans 10, 9, and 10. You know, I think that, you know, sinner's prayer is not something that's necessary.
You know, and the prayer is always different. But I'll have to say I don't have a problem with the prayer.
But I do want to say that it is not the prayer that saves someone. And that's where I think decisionism becomes such a problem.
We've developed all these external actions that can accompany salvation. And then we start treating actions as though they're the salvation itself. Did he repeat the prayer? Yes.
Did he raise his hand? Yes. Did he come forward? Yes. Did he tell the preacher he believed? Yes. Well, then he must be saved. But salvation is a work of God. We are saved through faith in Christ, not through performing a series of religious actions.
Like I said, I don't oppose a sinner's prayer in principle. A person who genuinely believes can certainly call upon the Lord. Romans 10 speaks about calling on the name of the Lord. But those words aren't magical. A person can repeat every word I say without trusting Christ. Okay?
In fact, that's part of my testimony. The first time somebody took me through the sinner's prayer, I didn't get saved.
I didn't believe. I was just repeating the words in my heart. I didn't say them out loud, but I was repeating it in my heart. But it wasn't a real genuine thing. That's part of my testimony. Okay?
I think the way we train people to do evangelism matters here. If I teach a teenager that the objective is to get somebody to repeat a prayer, then that's what he's going to work toward. If the person hesitates, he'll find another way to encourage him.
If the person doesn't know what to say, he'll give them the words. If the person repeats the words, he'll count that as a conversion.
And if we have a church culture where everybody's expected to report on how many people they won the Christ so they can, you know, go on the e-trip.
Okay? Now we've created an incentive to count decisions that we may not actually understand. And that's why I keep returning to 1 Corinthians 3. We plant. We water. God gives the increase. We should celebrate genuine conversions. Absolutely.
Though we should confuse our ability to secure a verbal response with God's power to regenerate a sinner.
Yeah. And, Brent, you would think that this is where the chapter ends. You would think. He said the prayer. We're good to go. But Howells continues on.
He continues by saying, not only are you going to do this, but you need to go tell your wife you're a Christian now. Then he begins discussing what Doug should do the following Sunday.
Now, this is a good point of follow-up. I agree with this. I believe baptism is part of what you should be doing as a public profession. But he tells him, you need to come to church on Sunday.
You need to walk the aisle. And you need to tell the congregation what happened here in your home. He explains that this doesn't necessarily mean that you're joining the church, but you're publicly acknowledged the profession of faith in Christ. And, again, this is a legitimate principle.
But, again, Christians should not be ashamed to say that we're Christ followers. Public confession matters. Biblical baptism is an identification with Jesus.
And we should be connected to the local church. But then the chapter gets so interesting here because Doug, whether he promises that he's going to come forward or not, Doug does agree, and Howes immediately goes into another repeat-after-me prayer.
He begins praying, promising that he's going to come to First Baptist of Hammond this following Sunday. He's going to be part of the conversation and walk the aisle. And this is where it began to catch my attention.
The first scripted prayer is about receiving Christ. The second scripted prayer is about promising to walk an aisle on a particular church on a particular Sunday.
And Howes has moved from calling a man to trust in Christ to having a religious promise concerning an action that Howes wants him to perform.
I think this is more revealing than even the entire part of the book because it's revealing how he is publicly identifying with Christ and how it can be attached to this extra-biblical institutional application that he lays out. This is where it goes off the rails for me. I'm just like,
this floored me. Okay? This is the part that bothers me the most. This is where that man of God coming in and nailing you down, and now I'm going to control what you do, comes in. You know, I understand encouraging Doug to publicly acknowledge his faith.
Do that. I understand telling him he needs to be baptized and become part of a local church. But where in Scripture are we told that somebody who trusts Christ in his living room needs to promise God he'll walk the aisle at First Baptist Hammond next Sunday? Okay? That's not a biblical demand.
I mean, that's church practice. Getting them to promise in a prayer that they're going to come to his church the next Sunday? That is insane to me.
You know, Howes has taken that practice and turned it into a promise to God. God?
I'm going to promise God I'm going to be at First Baptist Church next Sunday? It's almost like he was holding a gun to his head and said, tell God you're going to be at my church Sunday or else. Yeah.
Now, suppose Doug wakes up Sunday morning with the flu and suppose he has to go to work.
Suppose he decides to visit another church. Has he broken a promise to God now because Jack made a Jackie boy made him promise God he'd be at First Baptist? So Howes has unnecessarily placed that kind of weight on something that Scripture never specifically required.
Now, I think it just illustrates the difference between discipling somebody and recruiting somebody. Those are two different things.
We're either discipling them, but I think this comes into now we're recruiting somebody for our system. This man has just professed faith in Christ. What should we be concerned about?
We should be concerned about helping him understand the gospel, teaching him to pray, encourage him to read Scripture, helping him understand baptism,
connecting him with a healthy local church, and even, yes, inviting him to our church. I'm not saying I don't do that. I lead somebody to Christ. You know what? I pastor a church.
I go to this church. Why don't you come to my church on Sunday? You can walk the aisle at my church. You can, you know, get baptized at my church.
But what I'm not going to do is put a proverbial gun to their head and say, you better pray to God that you're going to be at my church Sunday or God's going to get you. Okay?
This chapter tells us that Doug later became a deacon. So apparently he did become deeply involved in church life. But as a model for soul winning, I think it's worth asking why the immediate emphasis falls on securing that public response at the pastor's church.
This was just outrageous. This part was just, it floored me. Yeah. I agree. Agreed is great as well. I think we need to also distinguish what the chapter demonstrates, what we can infer from.
Not everything is said here, but it demonstrates how's presented substantial gospel truth that Doug participated in the conversation, that he repeated a prayer professing faith, and that how's then secured a promise for public conversion.
The repeating of prayer, the repeating of public faith, all these things were there. It doesn't demonstrate what happened inside Doug's heart. It doesn't prove that he was manipulated into a false conversion.
In fact, the chapter introduction tells us that he later served as a deacon, as you said, and at least consistent with the continued Christian profession.
So we're not sitting here passing judgment saying, you know, Doug didn't have salvation. I don't think that's our place. What we are evaluating is simply the method being taught.
This chapter was included so others could learn how to win a soul. Everything How's did was for a reason. So when we teach a public method, we're communicating more than just information.
We're teaching them what success looks like. And this is what How's was showing here is if you want to be successful, you've got to do it this way. And when success is defined by getting a prayer said, a squeeze of the hand, a public confession,
getting someone to walk the aisle, then our method can quietly become a series of commitments trying to secure a number in a church.
And this is the concern that not only How's was was saying here, but that he was saying that Doug was showing this. So the concern is whether the methods teach evangelism to better to become better and obtaining responses rather than discerning whether the gospel was actually being understood.
And I think that's the main thing. I do a lot of when I do evangelism, I do a lot of follow up questions. I'm asking constantly, hey, did you understand that?
What what didn't you understand? How can we talk through this? And a lot of times it's not just the first conversation. It's two or three. I'm counseling a young man right now. He doesn't believe in faith.
His parents go to our church. And so I'm walking through the gospel in every one of our counseling sessions. And I'm starting to see those those little moments in life where he's starting to connect the dots.
And so I think it's important that we do that. I think it's important that we ask the questions. But I want them to be able to articulate what they're believing and why they're believing it. Right.
And I think this is this is where I think there's an important lesson for all of us, not just independent fundamental Baptist churches. OK, Southern Baptist can fall into this to contemporary churches can fall into it.
Anybody who measures success primarily by decisions can begin developing methods that produce decisions.
And we need to be willing to examine ourselves. And when somebody comes to me and says, Pastor, I want to be saved. I'm going to open the Bible and share the gospel. I'm going to explain sin, judgment,
Christ, death and resurrection, repentance and faith. I'm going to ask questions. I'm going to listen to the answers. If that person genuinely wants to trust Christ,
I'm going to encourage him to call upon the Lord. But I'm not going to treat I'm not going to treat the exact words of the prayer as a magical formula. I'm not going to manufacture certainly that, you know, that I don't possess.
You know, I don't think we should be afraid to leave a conversation unfinished. Sometimes a person needs more time to understand. Sometimes he has objections.
Sometimes he's interested but not ready to repent in that moment.
Sometimes he may be simply trying to please the preacher. That's OK in the sense that I don't have to force the moment. My responsibility is to faithfully communicate the gospel.
I can leave him with scripture. I can pray for him. I can continue the relationship. If you trust Christ, great, wonderful. But if he doesn't, I haven't failed merely because I didn't come away with a number to report.
The success of evangelism isn't determined by how effectively I close the deal. It's determined by whether I faithfully represent Jesus Christ. Let me say this one thing. I'm going to New Orleans Seminary. OK, I have filled out soul winning reports at Howes Anderson College and Tri-State.
And I fill out a weekly report at New Orleans. The difference is at both Howes Anderson and Tri-State, when I filled out the soul winning report, I had to lead somebody to Christ.
I had to stay out there. I had to doorknock. I had to go to Walmart parking lot. I had to stay with it until I led someone to Christ. Where in New Orleans, all I got to do is give the gospel to somebody. They might not even accept Christ.
But if I gave the gospel to them, that counts. And that's a biblical way to look at it. Yeah, Brett, one of the things that happens when someone leaves not only the IFB, but any spiritually abusive church is,
we call this the pendulum swing. The pendulum swing is, well, they taught me this over here. And so because it was flawed in some of their other teaching and manipulation and legalism, everything they teach is wrong.
And so the pendulum swings to the other side. I'm going to do everything opposite of what they taught me because nothing can be right.
And so I don't want the question to be what was right, what was wrong. Is personal evangelism right? Is personal evangelism wrong? I think we're called to share the gospel with people. And I think this is the heart of the question when we get to it. If someone hears the gospel clearly,
but never repeats a prayer after us, do we still consider that conversation worthwhile?
Because we've been driven in our hearts and our minds that unless someone repeats a prayer for me, unless someone walks the aisle the next Sunday, gets baptized, then what I have done is useless.
I hope that the answer to this question is, I've shared the gospel. I've clearly laid it out. I've done what I can do. The rest is in God's hand.
And I hope we would say, yes, that is great. Because the gospel is not this formula that we have laid out that people have to say or do.
And it's really, it's not a sales pitch. It's not sitting with someone and looking at that person as a customer saying, you know what, you've got to respond the way I want you to. This person is a human being. They're made in the image of God. They need the grace of Jesus Christ.
My job is not to pressure them into completing that transaction. My job is to simply share the truth, love them enough to answer their questions,
call them to repentance and faith, and continue to walk with them as they trust in the Holy Spirit to do what only the Holy Spirit can do. I just finished today preaching a chapel message at Rockwell Christian School.
And I finished my message, and I was preaching on Shamgar and what Shamgar did in the Old Testament where he killed 600 Philistines with an ox goad. It's been sort of my chapel message this year when I go and preach somewhere.
And I shared at the very end, I said, what is God calling you specifically to do?
I can't manipulate you and say this is what you've got to do. Each and every person here have a different gift, talent, and ability.
God may be calling you to do something that I will never be able to do because of your age and your influence and whatever you have. The question we have to ask ourselves is, what is God calling you to do? And I'm putting the response back on them.
Not trying to manufacture a response. Exactly. And I think that's a good place for us to finish because I don't want anybody listening to this episode and deciding that we shouldn't be bold in evangelism. Be bold. Tell people about Jesus.
Warn them about sin and judgment. Tell them that Christ died for sinners and rose again.
Call them to repent and believe. Don't apologize for the gospel. But at the same time, don't confuse boldness with pressure. Don't confuse somebody cooperating with your presentation with somebody being born again.
We ought to care far more about whether somebody genuinely knows Christ than whether we can count them on their report this week as another decision. And I think there's one thing that I would say to pastors and churches. It's this. Stop treating salvation like it's something we produce through a successful technique.
We can explain the gospel. We can plead with sinners. We can pray. We can disciple those who profess faith. But we cannot regenerate not the first person.
That's God's work. So don't turn the sinner's prayer into a formula. Don't walk the aisle into a – don't turn walking the aisle into a condition of salvation. Don't turn your church's preferred method into a biblical command.
Our calling isn't to close the deal, okay? Our calling is to proclaim Christ. Christ crucified. And when somebody genuinely trusts him, we rejoice because Jesus saved a sinner, not because we successfully completed our presentation.
And I think that's a good place to come to a stop. James, do you have any final thoughts?
No, I think it's good. I think that's a good word as far as what you said is our calling is not to close the deal. Our calling is to proclaim Christ, Christ crucified, and allow the word of God to pierce the hearts of individuals.
And, Brett, there's a lot of grace in a lot of what we've said. But I think the biggest amount of grace that God ever showed toward us, not only is his son dying for our sins, but that we get to be a small part in allowing someone else to come and know
our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ. He uses fallen humans to share the gospel. He doesn't call for angels to come down and share the gospel.
He doesn't call for the dogs of the world to come out and share the gospel. He looks at us as fallen human beings who are just as sinful, just as depraved as everyone else to be able to share the good news of Jesus with others.
And as our good IFB brothers say, if we don't share the gospel, who will? And we are called to share the gospel. We are called to win those who are lost.
We are called to expose them to the sin that they have done so that the gospel can be the thing that changes their heart and minds and lies ultimately back to Christ.
And I'm just grateful every time I get to share the gospel with someone, I'll get to do it tomorrow with a group full of young people.
I'm going to do it tonight with some kindergarten and first graders in our church because I'm doing the small groups for our young kids right now.
And I never take it for granted because that's an opportunity that I get to share Jesus with someone and I get to have a small part in an eternal salvation for their souls.
And so we should look at it as a tremendous honor that God has chosen humans to do that. So I'm thankful for that. Brett, thank you for the podcast. Thank you for your friendship.
Be praying for Brett as he transitions over the next couple of weeks to the new church here in Puckett and be praying for him. As always, we share.
Go and check out our website. Go and check out what we've got going on. Maybe you've missed a couple of episodes. Go back and listen to them.
Share these episodes with some friends. And we're closing in on finishing up the house church manual. We've got some good episodes in the tank ready to go on altar calls and some several different things.
And so we're excited about that. We hope you enjoyed our bonus episodes on worship and with our interview with Jonathan Allen Wright. And I know I enjoyed that. And I have been so encouraged by that episode as well. And so hopefully these have encouraged you.
And as always, to God be the glory. Great things he has done. Found my new name. Found that good grace. Found that healing. And the tears fell down my face. When I found my beginning. Has no ending. Found that second chance. Found my best friend. Found my forgiveness. Found my happiness.
I've been singing ever since. I found my freedom in you.
Thanks for listening to the 4-Freedom Podcast. If you enjoyed the content of the podcast, please do us a favor by liking, subscribing, or sharing the podcast on whatever podcast platform you listen to. Thank you.
Auto-generated transcript · 11,072 words. May contain errors. Select a timestamp to play from that moment.